Lesson objective

Apply a cut test to every segment of a session plan, protect the practice time, and hand the removed material to the person who can actually use it.

Plain-language explanation

Why this matters now

Every session design ends the same way: more material than minutes. The instinct is to speed up, which turns practice into description and leaves the room with a list. Backwards design gives you a better instrument. The behaviour on the first slide decides what stays.

Cutting is also a professional duty in this field, for a reason that has nothing to do with time. Material that does not serve the behaviour is usually material you know least well, and it is where the overstatements live: the borrowed statistic, the rule applied to the wrong population, the guidance described as binding. The segment you cut for time is often the segment that would have got you into trouble.

No source in this register validates any cut rule or any timing budget. What follows is instructional practice, labelled best practice.

A question to sit with

Take the segment you are most attached to. Write one sentence saying what a learner will do differently on Monday because of it. If you cannot, you have found your cut.

What goes wrong

1. Practice squeezed to make room for content. The practice round drops from thirty minutes to twelve so the model architecture slides can stay. The evidence never gets produced.

2. The scope that grew. The principal asks for "a bit on the new Colorado thing" and "something on carrier questionnaires", and a ninety-minute session on one behaviour becomes a tour.

3. The segment kept because it was expensive to build. Fourteen slides took a weekend, so they stay, although nothing in them serves the objective.

4. The cut that removes the caveats. The instructor trims the sentence naming the population and the date to save thirty seconds, leaving a bare number on the slide. That is the wrong thirty seconds.

5. Material cut and lost. Useful work that belongs to the principal, the operations manager or the carrier relationship is deleted rather than handed over.

6. Time for the room's own questions cut to zero. The hardest questions arrive at the end, and a session with no minutes for them sends people away with the wrong answer intact.

The practical answer

Best practice: apply a four-question cut test to every segment.

Question If the answer is no
Does this segment serve the behaviour on slide one? Cut it, or hand it to whoever owns that topic
Could I state its source, its jurisdiction and whom it reaches in one sentence? Cut it until you can
Would removing it change what the learner does on Monday? Cut it
Is it inside my role as an instructor rather than the agency's decision to make? Hand it to the owner instead of teaching it as settled

Best practice: sort what you cut into three piles, and deliver two of them. The first pile is material for another session, which you note in the session record. The second is material that belongs to a named owner: the principal who writes the agency rule, the operations manager who owns the templates, the person who answers carrier questionnaires. Send it to them in a short note. The third is material that should not be taught at all, usually because you could not source it properly.

Best practice: hold the caveats even when you cut the content. A figure without its population and date is worse than no figure. If there is no time to say who was asked and when, there is no time for the number.

Best practice: keep the licence line and the ownership sentence whatever else goes. Two things never get cut for time: who may perform the action in their state, and who reviews and owns the output. Everything else is negotiable.

Best practice: know what you are not qualified to decide, and hand it over. The IAIS Application Paper on the supervision of artificial intelligence notes at section 3.4.1 that third-party AI systems often give limited access to code and training data, which can challenge the effectiveness of human oversight, and mentions kill switches. It is international supervisory material that adds no new requirements and binds no US agency, and paragraph 20 says references to insurers should be understood as applying to both insurers and intermediaries unless stated otherwise. It describes a problem worth naming in a session. What the agency does about a specific vendor's opacity is the agency's decision, not the visiting instructor's, so that material goes in pile two with a note to the principal.

Best practice: budget the minutes against the evidence, not the topics. Work out how long the practice round takes to produce the artefact, protect that block, then fit description around it. The AM Best presenter's test in the August 13, 2026 draft minutes, concerning insurers and applied here by analogy, asks whether the reviewer has enough information, time and authority. The same question applies to your own session: if the practice block does not give learners enough time to do the check properly, you have scheduled a demonstration of hurrying.

Best practice: keep the unfair trade practices caution short and exact. Misrepresenting policy benefits, advantages, conditions or terms in a statement, sales presentation, omission or comparison is what state statutes based on Model #880 reach, and section 4B expressly covers electronic mail, internet advertisement or posting and other electronic means. The model defines "Insurer" to include producers, and section 3 treats a practice as an unfair trade practice if committed flagrantly and in conscious disregard, or with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice. State statutes vary in wording, penalties and scope. That is two sentences on a slide, and it is enough. A fifteen-minute tour of the whole model act is not what the room needs to perform the behaviour.

AI Coalition Network recommendation: record the cuts. Keep a line in the session record for every segment removed and where it went. When the principal asks why the session did not cover carrier questionnaires, you have the note showing you sent that material to the person who answers them.

Remember this

  • The behaviour on slide one decides what stays; everything else earns its place.
  • Apply the four-question cut test to every segment, and cut anything you cannot source in one sentence.
  • Protect the practice block; description gives way first.
  • Never cut the caveats, the licence line or the ownership sentence.
  • Hand cut material to the named owner rather than deleting it, and record where it went.

Insurance example

Wilhelmina Praeger, a fictional licensed producer and instructor, has a ninety-minute session for the fictional Quillfeather Insurance Partners with one behaviour on slide one: before an AI-drafted client message goes out, the licensed producer checks every coverage statement against the declarations and the form and notes the check on the activity. Her draft plan runs to a hundred and thirty-four minutes. She applies the cut test segment by segment. A fourteen-minute explanation of how language models are built serves nothing on slide one, so it goes. A nine-minute segment on international supervisory expectations is interesting but she cannot state in one sentence whom it reaches without a paragraph of caveats, and it changes nothing a learner does on Monday, so it moves to pile two with a note to the principal that the paper describes limited access to vendors' code and training data as a challenge to oversight, that it adds no new requirements and binds no US agency, and that vendor opacity is his decision to weigh. A twelve-minute walk through the whole state unfair trade practices statute shrinks to a two-sentence slide naming what the statute reaches and that state versions vary. An eight-minute segment on carrier AI questionnaires goes to pile two, addressed to the operations manager who answers them. A seven-minute segment on a new state AI statute goes to pile one for a future session, noted in the session record. That leaves eighty-four minutes. Wilhelmina then checks the practice block: the marked-up draft and the review note need thirty-two minutes to produce properly, and she has allowed thirty-two, so she leaves it alone and trims two minutes from her own demonstration instead. She keeps every caveat sentence, the licence line for the two unlicensed attendees, and the ownership sentence naming the licensed reviewer. She writes six lines in the session record: the segment cut, the reason and where it went. When the principal asks afterwards why carrier questionnaires were not covered, she forwards the note she sent the operations manager eleven days before the session.

Responsible-use warning

Never cut the practice block to protect a description segment; the evidence the session exists to produce disappears with it. Never cut the population, date or caveat from a figure to save time: cut the figure instead. Never cut the licence line or the ownership sentence. Never delete cut material that belongs to the principal, the operations manager or the carrier relationship; hand it over with a note, and record where it went.

Human-review requirement

The instructor decides the cuts within the session; the agency owner decides what happens to the material handed over. Before delivery, a licensed reviewer confirms that no caveat, licence-line statement or ownership sentence has been removed in trimming, that the remaining figures still carry their population and date, and that any segment describing what the agency should do about a vendor, a carrier questionnaire or a written rule has been passed to the person who owns that decision rather than taught as settled. The session record names every cut and its destination.

Practical exercise

Cut a session plan down to its behaviour. Use a fictional agency and a fictional plan throughout.

  1. Write the behaviour from slide one at the top of a page, in one sentence.
  2. List every segment of a draft session plan with its minutes, and total them. The total should exceed your session length; if it does not, add the segments you were tempted to include.
  3. Apply the four-question cut test to each segment and record the answers.
  4. Sort every cut segment into one of three piles: another session, a named owner, or not to be taught at all. Name the owner for every item in pile two.
  5. Write the short note you would send to each named owner, in no more than eighty words each.
  6. Recalculate the minutes after the cuts and confirm the new total fits your session length. Show the arithmetic.
  7. Time the practice block against the artefact it must produce, and state whether learners can complete it properly in the minutes allowed. If not, cut description until they can.
  8. Check every surviving figure still carries its population and date, and rewrite any that does not.
  9. Confirm the licence line and the ownership sentence survive, and write both out.
  10. Draft the session record lines listing each cut and where it went, and add one line for the material you decided not to teach at all and why.

Knowledge check

  1. What are the four questions in the cut test?

    Answer guidance: Does it serve the behaviour on slide one; can I state its source, jurisdiction and reach in one sentence; would removing it change Monday; and is it mine to teach rather than the agency's to decide.

  2. What gives way first when a session plan runs long, and why?

    Answer guidance: Description gives way before practice, because a behaviour that is only described is one nobody in the room has actually performed or produced evidence of.

  3. What must never be cut from a session for time?

    Answer guidance: The caveats attached to any figure, the licence line saying who may perform the action, and the ownership sentence naming the licensed reviewer of the output.

  4. Where does material about vendor opacity or carrier questionnaires belong?

    Answer guidance: In the pile handed to the named agency owner, such as the principal or operations manager, with a short note, rather than taught from the front as a settled decision.

Sources and further reading